Note: This post may contain affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission — at no additional cost to you. Learn more here.
Valentine’s Day does not need to feel like pressure to go all out or overdo it. A Valentine’s Day basket is simply a thoughtful way to do something nice for someone you love.
Instead of stressing about finding one perfect gift, this makes it easy to pull together a few smaller things that feel intentional when combined. Cozy, sweet, personal, and still elevated.
We curated everything below so you can build a basket by picking one item from each section. Follow the guide, mix and match from our selections, and you’ll end up with a Valentine’s Day basket that feels thoughtful without trying too hard.
How to Put the Basket Together
Before choosing the items, think about how the basket will come together as a whole. Presentation is what turns a group of gifts into something that feels curated.
Start with a base that can be reused and think in layers. Larger items should sit toward the back while smaller pieces are placed in front so everything is visible at once. This keeps the basket from feeling cluttered and helps each item stand out.
Texture also matters. Soft fabrics paired with structured packaging or glossy candy wrappers create contrast and make the basket feel full without needing too many items. If you are using a blanket, you can fold it slightly and let it act as both a gift and filler.
Finish it off with a small detail like tissue paper, a ribbon, or a handwritten note. These finishing touches are what make the basket feel thoughtful instead of rushed.
Step 1: Pick a Basket
The basket is the foundation of everything else. It sets the tone and determines how the rest of the items come together visually.
We recommend choosing something neutral, soft, or subtly festive that can be reused long after Valentine’s Day. Fabric baskets, woven bins, or structured totes all work beautifully and help the basket feel more like a keepsake than a one time gift.
Once you choose your basket, everything else will naturally fall into place.
Shop our basket selections below.
Step 2: Choose Some Plushies
A plushie is what gives the basket that unmistakable Valentine’s Day feel.
This is the playful, sentimental layer that makes the basket feel sweet without feeling cheesy. Plushies add softness, charm, and a little bit of fun that balances out the more practical items.
You can keep it classic or lean into something a little quirky. Smaller plushies tend to work best since they fit easily into the basket and can be styled later on a bed, shelf, or chair.
Browse our plushie selections below and add one or two that feel right.
Step 3: Add Some Sweat Treats
Sweet treats are where the basket really starts to feel fun.
This is your chance to lean into Valentine’s Day without overdoing it. Candy, chocolate, or nostalgic favorites add color, texture, and excitement to the basket. Mixing a couple different treats always feels more intentional than sticking to just one.
Explore our sweet treat picks below and add what feels right for her.
Step 4: Choose Something Cozy
This is where the basket really shines during winter.
Cozy wearables make the gift feel practical and indulgent at the same time. A hoodie paired with socks or a blanket paired with cozy socks is an easy combination that always works and feels thoughtful without trying too hard.
These pieces add warmth and longevity to the basket and are usually what she reaches for the most after Valentine’s Day is over.
Shop our cozy wearable selections below to round out the basket.
Step 5: Add Some Extra Random Goodies
The final layer is all about personality.
These extras are the small touches that make the basket feel curated specifically for her. Think little luxuries, everyday favorites, or fun additions that elevate her routine.
You do not need many of these. A couple well chosen extras are more than enough to make the basket feel complete.
Our Selections:
Final Tips
A Valentine’s Day basket does not need to be over the top to feel meaningful. When you focus on intention instead of excess, the result always feels more special.
Take your time, trust your instincts, and let the basket come together naturally. The best gifts feel cozy, thoughtful, and personal, not forced.